Double Club System

2NT Response System:
Continuations after 2C 2D; 2NT and Similar

Although the Double Club System's 2NT opening bid is artificial, we nevertheless need a 2NT Response System. If we open with an artificial 1C or 2C bid and (without any natural suit being bid by either partner) opener rebids 2NT then we need a 2NT Response System for the same reasons that standard bidders do over their 2NT opening bid.

After a natural 2NT rebid by opener, when no natural suit has yet been bid by either partner, we play a standard Extended Puppet Stayman system and red-suit transfers. Specifically, these are the following sequences where our 2NT Response System applies:

Extended Puppet Stayman

Extended Puppet Stayman will shortly be described in detail. However, since most readers will be familiar with Puppet Stayman, it may be useful for me briefly to describe the difference between that system and Extended Puppet Stayman.

In Puppet Stayman, responder enquires about opener's major suits by bidding 3C. Opener bids a 5-card major if he has one, bids 3D if he has a 4-card major (or both), otherwise bids 3NT. Extended Puppet Stayman is exactly the same except that opener additionally bids bids 3D if he has a 3-card spade suit. This enables responder, when he has 5 spades and 4 hearts, to find a 5-3 spade fit or a 4-4 heart fit if either exists.

Extended Puppet Stayman usually manages to right-side the contract but it will not always do so when responder has both majors. If you want something that guarantees right-siding of all major suit contracts then I recommend Muppet Stayman. However, Muppet Stayman has a number of counter-intuitive sequences, so it is suitable only for those partnerships who are prepared to put a lot of work into practicing something that will only occur infrequently, and who trust absolutely each other's memory and concentration. Selecting the best contract is more important than right-siding the chosen contract, and Extended Puppet Stayman will achieve that without taxing your memory too much.

The particular advantage that Extended Puppet Stayman has over standard Puppet Stayman is that it caters for responder's hand that has 5 spades and 4 hearts, saving our having to allocate the immediate bid of 3S for that purpose (as most Puppet Stayman players do). 3S is better used as Minor Suit Stayman, not least because it lets our 2NT Response System system mirror the pattern of three-level continuations by responder after a 1NT opening bid and a negative reply to 5-Card Stayman. Consistency of meaning in a bidding system is a goal worth seeking.

Responder's Strategy

Our 2NT Response System allows responder to find any 4-card or 5-card major held by opener by asking with 3C, Extended Puppet Stayman. Responder can show any 5-card or longer major suit that he holds by making a transfer, or show both minors and slam interest by bidding 3S (Minor Suit Stayman).

If responder has 5 hearts and 4 spades he can transfer to hearts and then bid spades. If responder has 5 spades and 4 hearts he must use Extended Puppet Stayman, which will identify either a 4-card heart suit or a 3-card spade suit in opener's hand.

Gerber: When partner's previous bid was either 1NT or 2NT (natural and balanced), then 4C is the Gerber ace-asking convention. Gerber is not used in any other circumstances.
Note: Your partnership may have different rules about when Gerber applies, or may choose not to use Gerber at all.

See below for some more detailed notes on Responder's Stratgegy in the less common situations.

Continuations by Responder

3C
Extended Puppet Stayman. Asks opener to bid a 5-card major if he has one, to bid 3D if he has a 4-card major (or both majors), or if he has a 3-card spade suit, otherwise to bid 3NT.
3D
Transfer to hearts. Promises 5 cards. Further bids by responder are natural.
3H
Transfer to spades. Promises 5 cards. Further bids by responder are natural.
3S
Minor Suit Stayman, showing minor suit slam interest and promising that responder is at least 4-4 in the minors. Opener is asked to bid a 4-card or longer minor suit, if he has one, otherwise 3NT. Further bidding is natural, so responder can follow opener's 3NT by bidding a 5-card minor if he wishes to look for a 5-3 fit.
3NT
To play.
4C
Gerber, asking opener to show how many aces he holds.
Note: If responder has a natural club hand that he wishes to show, he can start with 3C and follow with 4C on the next round. An immediate 4C bid is Gerber.
4D
Natural, showing a 6-card or longer suit. Responder probably has slam interest, so opener should cue bid with a fit or bid 4NT (natural) with no fit.
Note: When responder has slam interest and a diamond suit, he can investigate major suits on the way (if he also has a 3-card or 4-card major) by starting with 3C. His later bid of a minor suit is natural.

Further Notes on Responder's Strategy

Slam Interest with a 5-card Minor and a 4-card Major

When responder has slam interest with a 5-card or longer minor suit and a 4-card major suit, he should start with 3C (Puppet Stayman) to see if opener has a 4-card or longer major opposite his own 4-card major.

If opener bids 3D then responder next bids the major suit he doesn't hold, as normal, and if opener bids game in responder's major suit then all is fine: responder can bid slam, invite slam with a raise to five, or bid 4NT (RKB, since the suit is agreed) to check on Key Cards. But if opener bids 3NT, denying a mjor suit fit, responder can bid 4C or 4D to show a 5-card or longer suit. Opener will bid 4NT with only a doubleton, and responder will know whether to pass or continue.

If opener bids 3NT (showing 2 spades and 3 hearts), then opener must have at least 3 cards in each minor. Responder can bid 4C to set clubs as trumps or 4D to set diamonds as trumps.

If opener shows a 5-card suit that does not match responder's major suit, responder can bid 4C or 4D to show a 5-card or longer suit. Opener will bid 4NT with only a doubleton, and responder will know whether to pass or continue.

Slam Interest with a 6-card Minor

When responder has slam interest with a 6-card or longer minor suit, he probably will not be interested in any 5-card major that opener may hold. If his suit is diamonds he can bid 4D, showing a 6-card suit. If his suit is clubs he cannot bid a natural 4C (unless your partnership chooses not to use Gerber), so he must bid 3C initially and follow with 4C on the next round. This shows only a 5-card suit, but responder can insist on clubs on the next round.

Slam Interest with a 5-card Minor

When responder has slam interest with a 5-3-3-2 shape having a 5-card minor, he can start with 3C (Puppet Stayman), to see if opener has a 5-card major opposite his own 3-card major. If opener bids 3D then responder's 4C or 4D are natural, showing a 5-card suit and slam interest.

Author: Chris Burton
Gravesend Bridge Club